MODELS AND TERMINOLOGY FOR THE
ANALYSIS OF GEODETIC MONITORING
OBSERVATIONS
- Official Report of the Ad-Hoc Committee
of FIG Working Group 6.1 -
Walter M. Welsch
Institute of Geodesy
Bundeswehr University
Munich
Otto Heunecke
Geodetic Institute
University of Hanover
10
th
FIG International Symposium
Orange, March 19 through 22 2001
Commission 6
Concern of Deformation
Measurements
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
2
Engineering Surveying
is
involved in all phases of
the lifetime of a
construction
With respect to this report
only deformation
measurements are of
special interest
3
c
o
n
s
tr
u
c
ti
v
e
a
tt
ri
b
u
te
s
s
u
rv
e
il
la
n
c
e
a
c
ti
v
it
y
c
o
n
c
e
p
ts
/
e
m
e
rg
e
n
c
y
c
o
n
c
e
p
t
Stability and operational
security of a construction
Stability and operational
security of a construction
c
o
-o
rd
in
a
ti
o
n
ir
re
g
u
la
ri
ti
e
s
?
qualitative,
e.g. visual
inspections
quantitati
ve
- direct
- non
direct
Meaning of
deformation
measurements in this
interdisciplinary
context ?
- 1 0
- 2 0
- 3 0
- 4 0
- 5 0
S e t z u n g in m m
Concern of Deformation
Measurements
Security
concept for
construction
s
History of FIG Com. 6, WG 6.1 Deformation
Measurements
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
4
• 1
st
Symposium
Krakow
1975
• identification of unstable reference points in geodetic
networks
• continuous measuring techniques were just at the
beginning
• 2
nd
Symposium
Bonn
1978
•
1
st
Ad-Hoc Committee with the tasks of comparing
different approaches for the geometrical analysis
• 3
th
Symposium
Budapest 1982
• report of the 1
st
Ad-Hoc Committee
• expansion of deformation analysis into the physical
interpretation
• increasing importance of automated measuring
techniques
• 4
th
Symposium
Kattowice 1985
• 5
th
Symposium
Frederiction 1988
History of FIG Com. 6, WG 6.1 Deformation
Measurements
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
5
• 6
th
Symposium
Hanover 1992
• (partly) confusing terminology of technical terms
• 2
nd
Ad-Hoc Committee was set to work
(members: Milev / Pfeufer / Proszynski / Steinberg /
Teskey / Welsch)
• 7
th
Symposium
Banff
1993
• 1
st
progress report of the Ad-Hoc Committee (prepared
by Pfeufer)
• 8
th
Symposium
Hong Kong
1996
• status report on the topic (prepared by Welsch)
• 9
th
Symposium
Olsztyn
1999
• final report of the committee (prepared by Welsch /
Heunecke)
• panel discussion and recommendations
• 10
th
Symposium
Orange
2001
• official report includes recommendations and concludes
the work!
Geodetic Modeling of Deformation
Processes
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
6
Real Object
Model of the
Object
Geometr
y
Domain
The object is a
continuum
The object is
dissected by
characteristic
points
Time
Domain
The object is
(more or less)
perma-nently in
motion
The object is
monitored in
certain time
intervals
Conventional Deformation Analysis
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
7
The classical deformation analysis consists in a
purely geometrical comparison of the state of a
geodetic network
Main problem: identification of unstable
reference points by congruence analysis
Conventional Deformation Analysis
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
8
.
Cov
,
H
,
E
1
2
0
2
0
0
:
P
Q
l
o
x
H
x
A
l
h
d
Q
d
dd
T
1
0
1
2
0
2
H
|
F
s
P
,
f
,
h
global test of congruence:
The classical deformation analysis consists in a
purely geometrical comparison of the state of a
geodetic network
Main problem: identification of unstable
reference points by congruence analysis
null-hypothesis:
mean gap:
Kinemat
ic
Deform
ation
Analysis
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
9
Position x
Velocity x
Acceleration
x
= Finding of suitable
descriptions of point
movements by time functions,
especially by polynomial
approaches
...
²
2
1
...
²
)
(
²
²
2
1
)
(
1
1
2
1
2
1
2
t
t
t
t
dt
d
t
t
dt
d
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
View from
the GOCA
web-side
System
equation
X
,
Y
,
H
[m]
[mm/d]
[mm/d
2]
Advanced Deformation Analysis
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
10
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
Causal chain of a dynamic system
Modeling
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
11
Theory
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
Measurement
s
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
12
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
Empirical
results
Modeling
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
Evaluation
methods
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
13
Deviation between
computed and measured
system reaction?
Deviation between
computed and measured
system reaction?
- parameter
matching
• adaptive
• probabilistic
Measurement
s
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Modeling
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
Interpretati
on
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
14
-
conclusion on limiting
values of stresses
- prognosis of service
life
• verification of
results
• validation of
model
- model adaptation
Evaluation
methods
Deviation between
computed and measured
system reaction?
Deviation between
computed and measured
system reaction?
- parameter
matching
• adaptive
• probabilistic
Measurement
s
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
Modeling
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
System input:
• internal forces
• external forces
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
Determination of
• strain / stress
• displacements
• other indicators
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
Object:
• object geometry
• material parameters
• material behavior
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
System reaction:
• rigid body movements
• distortions
Potentiality of Dynamic Models
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
15
u n k n o w n :
o u tp u t q u a n ti tie s
g iv e n :
in p u t q u a n titie s
tr a n s fe r fu n c tio n
D i r e c t p r o b le m
u n k n o w n :
in p u t q u a n titie s
g iv e n :
tr a n s f e r f u n c tio n
o u tp u t q u a n ti tie s
In v e r s e p r o b le m
u n k n o w n :
tr a n s fe r fu n c tio n
g iv e n :
in p u t q u a n titie s
o u tp u t q u a n titie s
Id e n tifi c a tio n p r o b l e m
X
G iv e n a n d u n k n o w n q u a n titie s o f d y n a m ic s y s te m s
X
„design
problem“
during the
planning of a
construction
„back analysis“
often used in
geotechniques
“system
identification”
regular case
Hierarchy of Models in Deformation
Analysis
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
16
C o n g r u e n c e M o d e l s
K i n e m a ti c M o d e l s
D e s c r i p ti v e M o d e l s
S ta ti c M o d e l s
D y n a m i c M o d e l s
C a u s e - R e p o n s e M o d e l s
X
D e f o r m a t i o n A n a l y s i s M o d e l s
X
Deformati
on
Models
Congruen
ce
Models
Kinematic
Models
Static
Models
Dynamic
Models
Time
no
modeling
movement
s as a
function of
time
no
modeling
movement
s as a
function of
time
Acting
Forces
no
modeling
no
modeling
displaceme
nts
as a
function of
loads
and
loads
Methods of System Identification
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
17
• White box modeling:
Some basic considerations of the
monitored
system to be verified by measurements are
demanded
(„model approach“)
• Black box modeling:
Knowledge about the transfer
function is achieved only by measurements
(„operational approach“)
Causal Chain of a Dynamic System
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
18
Input signal:
Causative forces
Transmission
through the object
Output signal:
Deformation
System equation
• determination of deter-
ministic input quantities
• formulation of transfer
behavior e.g. by FEM
Observation
equation
• determination of the geo-
metrical reaction
KALMAN-Filter
• innovation
• system identification
Theoretical results
Empirical results
Load Trials on a Shell Structure Made of Bricks
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
19
Project in cooperation with architectures at the
University of Hanover, see Hesse et al. 2000
• prototype made of bricks was built in 1996
• dimensions 10,0 x 2,0 m, height 2,50 m
• steel bands between abutments for clamped
support
(Parametric identification, integrated
evaluation)
steel bands
Load Trials
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
20
service load
1,0 kN/m
2
expected load for
break down approx.
1,9 kN/m
2
maximum load
brought
up: 4,0 kN/m
2
24 load
steps
(March 24 1999)
semi lateral surface
loading
FE grid
13
33
Comparison
of computed
and measured
settlements
of points
No. 13 and 33
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
21
Standard deviations:
ANSYS
0,05 mm/step
Levelling
0,05 mm
Extensometer
0,01 mm
1
3
3
3
0,2
mm
1,0
mm
Results
of the adaptive
KALMAN-filtering
process
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
22
1
3
levelling
extensomet
er
filtered
0,5
mm
prediction
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
23
1
3
3
3
0,5
mm
0,5
mm
Results
of the adaptive
KALMAN-filtering
process
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
24
1
3
3
3
0,5
mm
0,5
mm
Global test of innovation,
= 5%
Results
of the adaptive
KALMAN-filtering
process
No. 33
No. 13
square sum
of residuals
Ground Subsidence at the Sparwood Coal
Fields
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
25
(Parametric identification, integrated
evaluation)
• movements caused by coal extraction, up to 2.5 m in
1980 / 1982
• suspicious discontinuity in the rock mass (fault), FE
modeling
• findings led to the closing of the mining operation
Project in British Columbia, details see
Chrzanowski et al.
faul
t
Non-Parametric Models
I
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
26
)
(
N
)
(
R
+
0
=
1
=
y
x
y
b
x
a
x
k
k
k-j
j
p
j
k-i
i
q
i
k
A
uto
R
egressive
M
oving
A
verage-
model:
recursive
part
non-
recursive
part
y
b
dt
dy
b
dt
y
d
b
dt
y
d
b
x
a
dt
dx
a
dt
x
d
a
dt
x
d
a
p
p
p
p
p
p
q
q
q
q
q
q
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
...
...
ordinary
differential
equation
most general description of a
S
ingle
I
nput -
S
ingle
O
utput
model:
• system identification means the estimation of
a
k
and b
k
• time series requested, no physical meaning
(‘behavior or black
box model’)
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
27
Non-Parametric Models II
y ( t )
y ( t )
g ( )
t -
t
x ( t )
x ( t )
t
E
in
fu
ß
gr
öß
e
D
ef
or
m
at
io
n
zurückliegende Werte einer
Gewichtsfunktion für zeitlich
Einfußgröße
t
t
single input y
single output
x
weight
function
non-
recursive
part
x
b y
y
k
j
k j
j
p
k
0
N ( )
0
)
(
)
(
)
(
d
t
y
g
t
x
SISO
approach based
on a convolution
integral:
Non-Parametric modeling of a turbine
plant
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
28
1 ,6 0
1 ,2 0
0 ,8 0
0 ,4 0
0 ,0 0
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
tim e [d a y s ]
d
e
fo
rm
a
tio
n
[
m
m
]
(
Project at the Bundeswehr University Munich, see
Ellmer 1987
)
• behavior of foundation pillars due to temperature
variations
• SISO identification, estimation of 30 significant
coefficients b
k
• diagnosis only symptom based, no physical
interpretation
measure
d
modeled
reaction caused by a unit impulse
of 1 K
Conclusion
Welsch, Heunecke: Models and
Terminology
29
We should make use of these
developments
!
• not all aspects of models and terminology are
treated in this presentation, more details can be
found in the paper
• orientation and classification on the basis of
system theory is recommended, system
identification is the tool for advanced analysis
• separation between models and methods is
important
• a commonly acknowledged terminology is a
requirement for an interdisciplinary approach to
problem solutions
• finally, during the last two decades, a significant
progress has been made from conventional
geometric descriptions of deformation processes
to highly sophisticated integrated models.