D

:

\

j

\

'

I

"':

I

Kl

J

U

Y

:

\

KEN

Y

A

CENTHAL

DANK

OF

K

ENYA

Dc

c

em

c

c

.

:

2

:2.

2

(

/

J

4

j

l:uie -'i'·;:"s

i

.

.

:

A

v

enue

1

'

.

0. Bo

x

6!;

<

XD

N

:

l

i

r

obi

K

e

n

y

a

Telepbo

ne

22

(;

-

n

j

Tc

ie

x

22124

The D

i

r

c

c

:

or

l\

en

y

a

f\n(

:

·

Ccrr

~

ptio

n

C

o

m

mi

ssi

on

L

1tcS

,-

i\

Ce

:

-.:

;

·c

r

)

O.G

o

:

-

:

6

:

~

3

)

C0

2

00

I

'

i

A

m

O

j"

~

I

D

e

l

l

r

Sir

l

\

£:

J[\VEST

I

GA

T

I

ON

OF ECONOMIC

CRIMES BY CHARTERHOUSE

BANK

L

T

D

AND

RELATED COMPANIES

'

Ne

i1C

h

~

o'

,

'

.

.I

CC:

:

?C r

ec

e

ipt of y

o

u

r

le

t

ter date

d

Decembe

r

15

,

2004 an

d n

ote wi

th

conce

rn th

e

hur

d

les y

ou

(

:H

C

be

ing

in ac

c

e

ss

ing information

fro

m

Cha

li

erhouse

b

an

k

.

A

l

tho

u

gh

-

we b

el

ie

v

e thut the

v

arious option

s

refe

rred t

o

in

yo

ur J

e

tt

e

r m

ay "

b

e

frau

g

ht

w

ith

c

i

e

!

c

\

ys

a

nd

c

o

unter

court

actions"

we

none

th

eles

s

are

o

f

th

e

view

th

a

t

it

wo

uld

b

e

l

1

p:

J

r

oj)r

i

C

1

lc for yo

u to

s

eek the opin

i

on

of

th

e Attorney

G

enera

!

in respec

t

o

f th

e h

urdl

es

y

o

u

a

r

c enco

ur

;:c

:'

in

g

in the course o

f

you

r

investiga

ti

o

n

e

speci

a

ll

y

ha

v

ing

r

eg

ard t

o

th

e

pow

e

rs

b

e

s

t

owe

d

upon

y

o

u by the statu

t

es

.

c

--

Ne

e

d

l

ess

to s

ay

, the Central

Bank wil

l

e

n

de

il

vo

ur

t

o fol

l

ow

'

u

p

w

ith

th

e ba

nk th

e

m

u

tt

e

r

s

r

i'

.

l

!sc

d i

n

y

ou

r

l

e

tter

i

n so f

a

r as they

r

ela

t

e

t

o co

m

p

l

i

ance

w

ith th

e

C

e

ntral B

an

k

o

f Ken

y

a

A

C

l

,

Bll

r

:

k

in

S

Ac

t

a

nd the R

eg

ulations

issued the

r

eu

nd

e

r

a

s we

ll a

s

th

e

Pru

de

nti

a

l

R

eg

ulations

is

sued by t

j

'~c

C

e

n

t

r

a

l

B

a

n

k

.

To fac

i

litute this

,

we wo

ul

d

app

r

ec

i

a

te

yo

w'

ava

ili

nq

to us

a

n

y

;xklit

i

oi

1

i:d

i"fc

l'

~

1

ill

i

i

on

o

f f

Cl

i

l

ur

e

/

r

c

fusal to pr

ov

ide

da

t

a by

t

h

e

C

h

a

li

er

h

o

u

se

ba

nk th

a

t

yo

u

wou

ld

w

.

sh to d

r

aw

to

o

u

r a

tte

nti

o

n so as to en

a

b

l

e us de

m

an

d

the s

a

me

f

r

o

m th

e

in

s

titution

.

You ,~:,,/

'

'

.'..si:

»

i

;(;1

8

,

ho

w

e

ve

r

,

t

h

a

t

the

inf

o:'ma

ti

o

n

gathered b

y

t

he Central Bonk can only

be i.scd

k

.

:·

"

.

ir

regu

la

to

r

y

functi

o

n

u

nd

e

r

t

he

B

a

nking

Act

arid

canno

t

be availe

d t

o yo

u

'

i

n

viev

,

o

f ~:~

(

;C()iISt

r

i:l

ii

it

s imp

os

e

d

o

n

t

h

e Ba

nk

u

nder

the

Ac

t

wit

h

reqa

r

d

t

o dis

c

l

os

u

re

o

f

i

:,:I

)

:

'

iL'i:i(

)

i~

l

)i

,

'

l

(

i

:

n

c

d

i

n

t

he co

urse

o

f i

n

sp

e

c

ti

o

'I

S

.

c

2

,=

-'

:

'-

.

c

:

:

.

::

.

_

..

.

~,

.~

_

<-

--

~

_

..~.

_

-

;;!.

.

.

.

\

.

•

•

0,

••

•

,

6;::

l0\

.

.

.

.:

.

~

.

'

<~

-

'

#. -

,

I

N

TH:I~:::~~;;:::=~::;

~

~

~

:;

"

:

'

~

;

'~;~~

\

'

\

CIVIL SUIT NO

.

329

OF

2006

...

~.

•.

.

;

.

;

,

"

f)

CE:

'

:

T:

:

:

::

'

.

:

"

:::

,,,

3

A~K

O

F

KE~YA

FIRST

'

DEFENDANT

:

\

,

:

I:

:

\

J

:Sr;:::j:

:

::

'

?O

R

F

I::

-

IA~CE

SECOND DEFENDANT

ROS

:

:

:

:

':>

::

'

:

'

:

:-

.

:

0

THIRD

DEFENDANT

V

E

RSU

S

'

:

;

REPLYING

AFFIDAVIT

I

,

GER.

:

'

-

+D

ARITA NY

AOMA

of

C

e

ri

t

.

a

l B

an

k

Building

and of Post Office

,

B

o

x

N1

.

:

.

.

m

be

r

6000

0

Na

irobi

in the

Republic

of Kenya

do hereby

make

o2

<

h

3

,

:::

;('

.

s

ta

t

e

a

s

follow

s

:

-

1.

7

HAT,

I am

th

e f

irst D

e

feric

.

a

n t

'

s Director,

Banking

Supervision

:

:

>:

:

p

2

.

r

t

m

c

n

t a

r

i

d

I

r

u

n

du

.

y

au

t

horised

by

it

to

swear

this

;

·

,

.

~-f

id

2lv

i

t

on its be

r

ra

l

f

and

c

on

f

irm

t.hat

,

I am fully conversant

.

·.<~

ht

he facts

depo

ned

to

i

n this

affida

v

it

and

can

positively

~\

.

.

.

c

a

r

t

he

re

t

o

f

rom

'

my

p

e

rs

o

na

l

knowledge.

TtI

AT,

I

ha

ve

read and

un

d

e

rstood

the conte

n

ts

of the Chamber

Sur

nrn

o

n s d

at

ed

the 23

rd

d

ay of

Jun

e

,

2006 and the affid

a

vit in

s

u

ppo

rt

t

h

e

r

e

of

swor

n

by o

n

e

S

a

njay

Sh

a

h

on the same

dated

.i

nd

s

t

a

te t

hat I mak

e

t

his

affidavit i

n r

e

sponse

t

h

e

reto,

TH

AT,

the f

i

r

s

t

D

e

fendant

i

s

a

s

tatutory

bod

y

established

under

:

-

,'

:

:p

r

c

vi

s

io

r

;

s c:

S

ec

t

i

o

n

3 of the

Cent

r

al

B

a

nk

o

f K

e

n

ya

A

c

t

,

:

.:

-

,<~

:

c,

~

~0

:

:

'

o

f tr.e

L

aws

of Kenya

and

o

n

e

o

f i

ts

p

r

in

c

ip

a

l

,',

:

J.:c;

C

':S

i

s tc

:-

cg

-

ula

t

e the op

e

r

a tion

s o

f a

l

l co

mm

er

c

ia

l

banks

i

n

"

,

-~---'----

'

--

----

.•

....

=

--

~

'.

",,

-

-

•

.

•

'

-

..

"

-=-

...

;

.

..-

-

-

-

-

-

=

-

-------

-

-

------------

-

/

debts.

/

>

:"

:

~\

'

e

s

trie r

egular

i

nspectio

-;

of t

he

ope

r

a

t

i

ons

a

nd

a

f

fa

irs

of

.

-

-:

..

:

:

:

c

:·

.

..

~:

.

c

J

b

an

.

cs

L:C

en

sur

e

:

h

a

t

the

barik

s

co

m

p

l

y

with

the

=;:

"

:

'

:

:

s

~

o

:-

,s of 2

J

~ ~11

e

~

2

.

-,Vsapp

l

icable

t

o

t

hei

r

o

per

at

ions

together

'.

--

:

:~-:

.

ccc;::1i:1ist.ra:ive guideli

ne

s

is

s

u

ed

b

y t

h

e

Central

Bank,

as

.

.

.

.

.

..

:

J

.

]

:

~

;

:

'

:

.

?

,"

l

',

during

t~1e cour se o

f a

re

gu

l

ar

inspection

of the Plaintiff

,

·

.:

.

.

.

.

.

e

r

t

aken

by

the

fi

rs

t

D

c:

enda

n

t's

Banking

Supervision

:

=

:C

:

:

2

.

rt

m

en

t

in A

ug

u

s

t

,

2004

p

ursuant

to the

first

D

e

fendant

'

s

s

.

a

;

i

to

r

y

m

a

n

da

t

e

u

nder

Sec

t

ion

32( 1) of the

Banking

Act,

a

:

~

i

.

:

:T

.

be

r

of vio

l

a

ti

o

ns

of

t

he Ba

r

.k

ir

ig

Act were cstabli

s

h-r! viz :_

.

(a)

L

e

n

di

ng

to both

N

a

kumatt

Holdings

Limited

and

Trito

n

P

e

trole

um

Limited

in excess

of the single

borrow

er

l

i

mit

o

f 25

%

of its core capital

.

(

c

)

L:volveme

nt

in

in

sid

e

r

l

e

ridrn

g

withou t

a

dequate

secu

r

it

y

and

a

b

o

v

e

the prescribed

limit

of

20%

of its

C

ore c

api

tal

.

(

c

)

Inadequat

e

pr

o

vis

i

ons

for

bad

and

doubtful

(

d

)

Fail

ur

e

b

y

the

Pl

a

i

ntiffs

management

to submit

a

ccurate

returns

to

t

he

first D

e

fendant

.

(

a

)

r

\

number

of

custome

-

account

s

la

c

ked

account

c,

;

;c

r:

:

.

::

-

-

.

g

d

o

cur:--

.

:

:ntation

as

per

the

kn

o

w

your

C

u

st

o

mer

proc

e

d

u

res.

~"

Ij

i/.

.

.

T,

r

o

ilow

i

ng

these

f

i

nd

ing

s,

the managem

e

nt

of the

Pl

a

intiff

-

,

:

>

-

~~::

(

;

:,

t

r,

e v

i

orat

.

ons

where

u

pon

the f

irst

D

e

fe

nd

a

nt

imp

o

sed

a

nd

t

h

e

P

l

ain t

i

f

fs

Ma

n

a

ging

ac

ti

o

n

woul

d

b

e

underta

.

ken

::

,

:

,

~

iT.

e

d

y

the

vi

o

l

a

t

.or

,

s.

(

,

?;

;

:::

•

.:

~

T

,

t

r

ie firs

:

d

efe

r

id

arit

un

de

r

too

k

a f

o

l

l

ow-up

inspection

In

:>

:·

~

:"

.

:2

~~,

2

0

0

5

".

:

0

es

tablis

h

t

.

i

e

s

t

atus

o

f c

o

mplian

ce

and

the

;

:

.

. z:

.

:

..•

-

:::i

:m c sta

b

i

i

s

ne

d

tha

t

r

em

edi

a

l

acti

o

n

had

be

e

n

taken

on

IT

:

;

)S

:

0

:-

the vi

ol

ati

o

n

s

w

i

t

h the

e

xception

of those

relating

to the

"

;

~.

:"

lj

;

.

!

)

you

r cus

t

ome

r

p

r

o

c

e

dur

es

'

.

8

.

T3AT,

as a

r

es

u

lt

of the reme

d

i

a

l

action

taken

by the Plaintiff,

c:

-.

(

~

f

ir

s

t

Defe

r

id

a

.

nt

recomme

n

ded

and

received

the

second

Dc

f

erid

a

rr

t

's

ap

p

r

ov

a

l

to renew

t

he Plaintiff's

license

for the year

.'

9

,

t

h

e

f

i

r

s

t

D

e

f

e

nda

n

t

u n

c

e

rt

oo

k

a

noth

e

r

inspe

c

tion

of the

.

•

:

'

>

,

:

;~j:

'

[

i

n

O

c

tobe

r

,

20

0

5

wh

.

c

h

reve

a

led

i

sornc

weaknesses

Y

.

i

:

:

:

::

:

-:

.

.

the

o

p

e

r

a

ti

o

n

s

of th

e P

l

a

intiff

including

non

-

compliance

(

<;

", ::.

,

'

~

:~e

regu

l

a

tio

n

e

n

cl

as

s

if

i

c

ation

o

f loan

s

and

th

e

'Know

!

.

J'j

,

'

.

U

·

c

u

sto

m

e

rprocedur

e

s

'

;

T

h

e

inspection

report

was

availed

tc

·

c;

--

.

c

Pl

aint

if

f

w

h

o

accept

ed

i

t

s

f

indings

and

undertook

to

r

c

.

i

.

c

c.y

t

h

e

v

i

olatio

n

s.

10

,

T~bJ

::

,

i

:::

C

f

i

rst

Defe

n

dant

u

r.dcrtoo

k

a

n

o

t

h

e

r

i

ns

p

ec

tion

in

'

.

[

'

"

1

.

/

::

-

:

:

,

2

0

0

6

which

revealed

t

he

fcllow

ing

:-

~

•

•

.

•

•.

•J";,

_

'

•

_

_

•

."

."..-

----

---

--

-~.

_

.

•.

--

_

..•

.

•..

-_

.

_

-

-

_

..

_

-

-_

.

_

.

.

_

_

.

-

-..

-

..

-

.

t

.

.

T

•

(

0

)

ACCO'-

.

'

"

J

.

" oper..ng

for

ms

of

45 custome

r

ac

c

ounts

we

r

e not availed.

1

i

(c)

Ti

le

engclger

:

.

l

cnt

i

n

o

f

f

sh

o

r

e

mo

n

ey

transfers

inv

o

lving

sp

L

t

in

g

of

t

r

an

s

actio

ns

was found.

(

ci

)

C

i

-

:

c:;

,

ue

s

d

r

a

w

n

on a cu

st

o

mer's

account

were

cl

e

ar

e

d

t

h

r

o

u

g

h

a lawye

r

'

s

c

l

ient acc

o

unt

.

(

c

)

Th

e

s

a

me

1

2

,

'

,vy

e

r'

s

c

li

e

n

t

a

cc

o

unt

w

as

being

used

as

a tr

ad

ing

a

ccount

for some customers.

1

C

o

.

:

[

I

V

.

:

.

T,

t

he

dr

a

ft

i

ns

pec

ti

o

n

re

p

o

rt

wa

s

f

o

r

w

ard

e

d

b

y

the first

0

c:

:

'

:

e

r

"

da

nt

to

t

he

Pl

a

intiff

on 2

1

s

t

June,

2006 for comments

by

t

.

.

...

<;

;

n-:2,

n

ag

c

:

;:n

,

:

n

t

.

:

.

\

,

I

ea

n

w

h

i

1

e

·

,

a

d

ve

r

s

e

r

epo

rt

s/

allcgntions

on the

P

i

ai

n

t

i

f

f

we

r

e

tabl

e

d

in parl

i

a

m

e

nt

and

in light

of this

and

in

o

r

d

e

:

:

to

pr

o

t

ect:

th

e

i

ntere

st

o

f the

Plaintiff's

depositors

and

c

:

'

~ci

;

;:c

:

'

s, the

fir

st

Def

e

n

d

a

J~

t

s

o

ug

ht

a

nd

r

e

cei

ve

d

th

e

second

:

:

-

.J-

'

:

:"c

n

c:

a

n

t'

s

ap

pr

ova

l

t

o

p

l

a

c

e

the

Plaintiff

under

statutory

::'~

:

-:.:

"

"

a

.

;e

=:

e

r:

t

1

:1

s

t

r

i

ct

exe

rc

i

s

e

of power

s

ve

sted

on it b

y

the

(

.

,

r

..

.

..

L,

}:

.

~Ji

T

,

f

rom

the

fo

r

e

g

oi

ng

=

v

e

rily

b

elieve

tha

t

th

e

Plaintiff's

;·:

:

'

:j)~

:

c2,

t

i

o

n

·

da

ted

the 23

rd

d

a

y

o

f

June,

20

0

6 has

no merit

and

~

o

.

:

:

::

~

:

c:

ri

ot

b

e

s u s

t a

i

n e

d by

t

ni

s H

o

n

o

u

rable

Court

a

nd

confirm

.:::

.

?

,;

:

wh

at i

s

de

p

o

n

e

d

h

e

rei

n

above

i

s

t

rue

to the

best

of my

:

.:

:.

.

.

.

owledg

e

.

SW

O

H

H

:.

:

;~

.

.

·

~:-:

.

c

sa

id

GERALD

)

)

)

(

'

J

~

C

\

.

.

~<

.

/v

-------

-6

~)

-

-

---

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-------

-

-

..

•

-

..

••

.•....•.

.

""

-

~

--

-

-_

.

.

.

i

I

i

,

~

3:S~C

:

X-~ :

'

rl

E

::

,

,

1\

VA

)J

G I

tHEG

~

AD\

lOCATE

,

CO

:

\::

'

f

I

SS

IO~Z:~

?Cl

~

CW

I'

-

s

P

O

B

c

x ,

590

7

,

OC

2

\j

!

)

~

:

~m

c

:

:

1

"

T"

l

'

~

~

S9

I

lf

:

i

;

~

Q::j

:

:

\

=

n

~

S2

:0

N

ER

F

OR

O

ATHS

D

RA.V

T

S

&

F

ILE

D

B

Y

:-

ox

...

s

.

:

:

:'~~

&

C

O

~

I

P

A

NY

AI

J

VO

CA

T

E

S

3

R:

)

FI

.

OOR

A

C:

':

(

C"

.

c

.

R

DE

N H

O

U

SE

:

:

,:

;

'

I

:

2

.

5'

I'

:

:

~

G

C

H

G

AVE

N

UE

1

:

)0

D

C;

:

;

:

:

51

236

NAlR

O

B

I

\

(

-

.

"

,

--

-

-

-

-

-

-,---

------------

-

-

--------_

-.

:

-